top of page
  • Writer's picturewhitbydrywall

Drywall Taping: Paper Tape or Fiber Mesh Tape?

Which one to use, and does it really matter?


Drywall Taping renovation

In the world of home improvement, few tasks are as simultaneously pivotal and perplexing as drywall taping. As a homeowner or DIY enthusiast, you might find yourself at a crossroads when it comes to choosing the right tape for the job – traditional paper tape or the newer, fiber/mesh tape? With countless hours spent honing my craft, in the 20+ years of experience I have under my belt, I understand the intricacies of drywall taping like the back of my hand. In this post, I'm going to guide you through the material choosing process, offering insights and solutions to common mistakes that often impede the taping process. Whether you're a seasoned pro or a rookie DIYer, there will be something for everyone.


Lets dive in!



Drywall Tape: What's The Difference?


Drywall paper tape is a traditional option that consists of a durable paper strip with an embedded center crease, while drywall mesh tape is a more modern alternative made of fiberglass threads, forming a mesh strip, almost like a super strong gauze. The key distinction lies in their composition and application, each offering unique benefits and drawbacks in the realm of drywall taping.

Trust Me: My Mistake, Your Success


Having used both extensively, I can offer plenty of advice. But it isn't completely black and white. Like this page. It comes down to what the application is. Are you patching a baseball sized hole in the house, or are you drywalling a newly constructed home? Both have their merits, and both have their downfalls.


So before purchasing your materials, read below to learn about the pros and cons of each, and consider the project you're about to undertake.


Paper Tape: Pros and Cons


Drywall paper tape has its own set of advantages and disadvantages. Here's a breakdown of what to expect:


Pros:


Durability: Paper tape is known for its long-lasting performance. It can withstand the test of time and maintain its strength, making it a reliable choice for seams and corners.


Smooth Finish: When applied correctly, paper tape can yield a very smooth finish when the mud dries on top of it. It's ideal for achieving seamless transitions between drywall sheets.


Cost-Effective: Paper tape is generally more affordable than mesh tape, and can be used on every area of a project, making it a budget-friendly option for DIYers and professionals.


Cons:


Requires Skill: Applying paper tape effectively can be a bit tricky and may require some expertise. It's less forgiving of mistakes compared to mesh tape.


Time-Consuming: The application process of paper tape typically involves more steps and can be time-consuming, mostly for beginners.


Susceptible to Cracking: In areas prone to shifting or settling, paper tape may be more susceptible to cracking over time, when not applied correctly.


In summary, drywall paper tape is a durable and cost-effective option for taping drywall seams, but it demands a higher level of knowledge and skill during application. It's a solid choice when done right, but it may not be as forgiving as mesh tape for those new to the taping process.


Mesh Tape: Pros and Cons


Fiberglass Mesh Tape can be your best friend and your worst enemy. Here's why:


Pros:


Ease of Use: Drywall mesh tape is incredibly user-friendly, making it an excellent choice for DIYers and beginners. Its self-adhesive backing simplifies the taping process, as it has a very light adhesive, and sticks to the wall when applying. Almost zero learning curve when applying to joints.


Flexible and Versatile: Mesh tape is more flexible than paper tape, allowing it to conform to curves and corners with ease. This versatility makes it a great choice for irregular surfaces.


Just Start: Due to its flexibility and the fact that it spans gaps rather than covering them, mesh tape doesn't require prefilling large gaps or holes, when used with powdered setting compounds like Durabond or Sheetrock.


Cons:


Durability: While mesh tape is durable, it may not be as robust as paper tape over time, and can sometimes fray when unrolling, if the user is not careful. Although not detrimental in the immediate, it can be quite annoying during application.


Cost: Mesh tape is typically more expensive than paper tape, which might be a consideration for those on a tight budget.


Versatility: Simple to use right out of the gate, will generally come with limiting results in almost all products. Mesh tape is not recommended for inside or outside corners. Also, fiberglass mesh tape cannot be used with premixed compounds. Setting powders like Durabond, Sheetrock, or other high-density setting powders should always be used to ensure it does not not crack.


In summary, drywall mesh tape is a user-friendly and flexible option that's great for beginners and complex surfaces. It's less likely to suffer from water damage, but it may not be as durable over time, and its cost can be higher compared to paper tape. The choice depends on your specific project needs and personal preferences.


End Result: That's Where it Counts



Hopefully this has helped answer some questions you may have had, concerning drywall taping and some of its many products. Whether you are using paper tape or fiberglass mesh tape, these simple guidelines, will help you along the way. Drywall Taping takes practice, and there are many ways, with many different tools and products, to complete a job successfully. In the end, what's important is that you take the time to do it to the best of your ability and always follow manufacturers specifications. Good Luck!


Trusted Drywall Paper Tape and Fiberglass Mesh Tape Manufacturers:



15 views0 comments
bottom of page